Demons, Caves and Death (NefHxMotherhood)

cavechurchsht

cod_gabriel, flickr

Prehistory is, as its name suggests, before written records. Prehistoric birth rituals, are, therefore, lost to time.

Anthropologists look to primitive contemporary cultures, with little or no exposure to Western medicine and philosophy, to try to fill in the gaps.

This, unfortunately, is as fraught with hazards as childbirth itself. Even the great Margaret Mead got some egg on her face making generalizations from observation of a “primitive” culture–it turns out that primitive teenage girls, like our teens, are capable of making up great stories.

Nonetheless, that’s all we’ve got. Take them, as with everything, with a grain of salt (or a glass of wine).

The Aborigines of Australia believe that the spirits of unborn children live in the rivers and streams. When a woman wades into the water, the spirits pick good mothers (great excuse, yes?).

The Kayapo tribe of Brazil has a similar legend about the forests. They have an elaborate fertility ritual, wherein they are brushed with leaves, bound with vines and drink an elixir of bark. We don’t have any data on how well this works, or if failure to complete the ritual is an effective form of birth control.

Caves, with their obvious female symbolism, were the home of the Great Goddess, and commonly part of fertility rituals among pagan cultures in Europe and elsewhere. As were holes in trees.  In difficult labors, women were occasionally passed through these tree holes, or carried into caves, as a form of sympathetic magic.

[Men are capable of taking over even this blatantly feminine imagery. The Mithra cult of Persia and Ancient Rome often met in caves, symbolizing the death and rebirth of the Sun God. Mithraism was an exclusively male club.

The early Christians viewed Mithrasim as a subversive parody of their religion (let's see, dead and reborn god, hmmm...), despite the fact that Sun God worship is as old as the caves themselves. They collapsed entrances to caves and forbade rituals in them. Many churches are built at the mouths of caves, as ancient sites of worship (of both Mithras and the Great Goddess) were co-opted.]

Midwives often were more involved in the supernatural aspects of birth than in the mechanical delivery of the child.

In the desert tribes of Algeria, the midwife delayed the birth by holding the head of the child and preventing further delivery. Why subject the mother to this torture? It enlightened the child by keeping him at the mystic border between life and death.

Swahili wise women singed off the pubic hairs before the birth, to smoke out any demons residing there. Cutting or shaving just didn’t have the demon protective quality of fire.

After the birth, the Bolivian Quechua tribes hide the blood, making sure that it never gets outside, where the evil spirits might notice it and come after the woman and child in their vulnerable state. They also spread grain around the entrance to the house, making it clear to the spirits that the household  is too large to attack.

It seems that primitive societies believed that childbirth was the prerogative of the child. Faced with a difficult birth, Native Americans would often attempt to scare the child out, by nearly running the woman down with a horse. Or they suspended her from a tree, and bounced her up and down, pulling on her belly with ropes.

If all else failed, of course, the women would call in the laboring men from the field, who would carve out the child piecemeal, attempting at least to save the mother.

If this seems harsh, remember that the word “deliver” was not, ever, intended to refer to the child. It was about the woman, and her torment. “She should be safely delivered.” It was not until the development of operative obstetrics in the late 19th and early 20th centuries that the fetus became a life of its own, separate from the mother whose life it regularly stole.

Women died in childbirth. Routinely. Commonly.

How many?

It’s not hard to fathom that we don’t have maternal mortality records for prehistoric times. But, in fact, we have no attempt to even collect these statistics until the mid-nineteenth century. Then, the earliest numbers were that about 6 in every thousand laboring women died (a number that, despite male meddling, stayed fairly constant until the mid-1950s). That rate parallels those reported in non-Westernized societies today.

As much fun as we will make of the wackiness of the history of obstetrics, that history has combined to reduce maternal mortality in developed countries to the current 0.1/1000 in the US.

Feel free to kiss your obstetrician.

Click here for the full series, in case you missed anything…

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

Related posts:

  1. The Couvade (NefHxMotherhood)
  2. The Divine Mother and Child–NefHxMotherhood
  3. Mummies and Mommies–NefHxMotherhood
  4. The Nefarious History of Motherhood
  5. The One True God v. The Goddess (NefHxMotherhood)

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

Add to Technorati Favorites

13 Comments

This insightful post is why I enjoy your writing! As a scientist, mother and wrestler of boys, I love your take on things. I’m passing along the “Splash Award” to you that was given to me this week. Check out the other blogs I tapped – you might enjoy reading some of them also.
thanks for supporting my blog and keep up YOUR good work!

Myrna’s last blog post..Splash Award

[Reply]

I knew these would be interesting. Looking forward to your next installment!

The Dental Maven’s last blog post..Remember When Anybody Could Afford To Buy A Toothbrush?

[Reply]

I can’t imagine how hard it was to be a women in those scenarios.

Or maybe it just seems hard from where we stand now.

Either way, that was a fascinating post.

ck’s last blog post..you’re right

[Reply]

Great post, very interesting. I think I would have probably curled up and died.

[Reply]

I had an epidural with my first two girls and would have with the third if it weren’t for an emergency c-section with th second. I can’t imagine a home birth. I might have forgone sex just to escape the pain.

Drama Queen Jenner’s last blog post..Wendsday, Wonderful Wednesday

[Reply]

Six in every thousand? I’d have thought it would be more. But the Swahili singing is even more shocking. And I’m certainly grateful no one tied me to a tree to deliver me!

The Lawyer Mom’s last blog post..The Joy of Boys

[Reply]

I agree with Lawyer Mom – I thought it would be more, too. Considering I read some article about third world women having a huge birth mortality rate. But, then, to think I live in a town of about 25,000, with roughly half being women (12,250) Then let’s say since it’s old days, where it was our job to spit ‘em out, 2/3 of them get pregnant (8,166ish) that means 50 women in my town would die in childbirth that gestational period. Yikes! That’s like 50 funerals every 9 months.

So my estimates are completely wrong, but my point is – that’s way more women than nowadays.

I like the water myth though – If you happened to have a partner with low sperm count, you weren’t good enough to be a mother… loser.

And – At least they tried to save the woman instead of the baby.

Liz’s last blog post..Retarded Social Myths: Debunked

[Reply]

Okay, so now I totally understand the reason why I was born during the time I was meant to come into this world. No way would I ever be able to deal with those rituals or beliefs. The one about the midwife holding the baby’s head so the baby couldn’t be delivered right away….it just sounds cruel and torturous, for both mother and baby.

I just love your writing….I always leave your blog feeling more insightful!

Helene’s last blog post..Dear Supernanny,

[Reply]

I like the idea of the delivery being about the mother and her torment. LOL.

It’s amazing to see how culture and time changes the evolution of the childbirth experience.

Great series and great research.

Maria@Conversations with Moms’s last blog post..I can feel my Estrogen levels decreasing

[Reply]

I didn’t get past having pubic hairs burned off. Oh, shit.

It’s interesting how much we lost in the dark ages. Cesarean section was developed in ancient Rome. Great medical advances were made, then lost for a thousand years or more.

With my son I dropped a softball-sized clot after my placenta shredded during childbirth. He was born with the cord wrapped around his neck and needed oxygen for a few minutes right after birth. In 2003 this was a simple, common complication. Even a hundred years ago we probably both would have died.

I’m so glad to have been born when I was…

Wendy’s last blog post..Peking Dog

[Reply]

themother Replies:

There is some controversy over the name “Caesarian”, but most scholars chalk it up to some law codes that were put into effect in Imperial Rome requiring that the fetus be cut out if the mother died. Some think it was because it was a grand operation, worthy of the name of the grand Caesar. But it most certainly wasn’t done to deliver Julius Caesar, whose mother lived well into his political life.

Cutting the fetus out of a dead or dying mother is far older, dating back at least to ancient days. There are references in the Greek myths and in the Talmud.

For the mother to survive the section, however? That had to wait until the 1750s. While there is a case of a pig farmer in the 1500s who supposedly delivered his wife by section–then fathered a few more with her that were born the normal way–there is some debate as to whether what he described was a full term ectopic, extrauterine pregnancy.

The first recorded case of a woman surviving Caesarian section was in the 1750s, delivered by an Irish (woman) midwife.

Until the development of anesthesia and antisepsis, however, the mortality rate was over 85%.

Don’t put too much stock in the wisdom of the ancients (or popular wisdom about the wisdom of the ancients). We’re about to tear it all to shreds.

[Reply]

The image of the midwife holding the head of a crowning child sticks with me. Trying to prolong that moment does indeed seem torturous. We owe a lot to modern medicine certainly. I don’t think I’d be here without the handy work of my first OB that delivered my daughter via c-section. She was double wrapped in her cord and going nowhere after 13 long hours. Thank modern discoveries he didn’t string me up to a tree or try the stampede method to “scare” her out. Love this series.

mrsbear’s last blog post..Sigh…Bathing Suit Season

[Reply]

Get. That. Torch. Away. From. My. Vagina.

That’s all I was thinking after the bit about singeing the hairs.

Great piece Mother. Looking forward to more.

AmyAnne’s last blog post..The Family That Eats Together

[Reply]

Leave a Comment